(Answered) Suppose you are an instructor of ECON 4211 interestedin the causal effect of holding review…

Written by

in

Suppose you are an instructor of ECON 4211 interestedin the causal effect of holding review sessions on final exam performance. You devise thefollowing strategy: across a series of semesters t = 1, . . . , T , you randomize review sessions tosome semesters while in other semesters you do not hold a review session. You then recordthe final exam score Yit of student i = 1, . . . , N in semester t (for simplicity assume the samenumber of students N enroll in each semester). Let Rit = 1 if semester t had a review session,with Rit = 0 otherwise.
(a)
Consider a difference-in-differences approach which compares trends in average test scoresacross semesters (t − 1, t) where Ri,t−1 = 0 and Rit = 1 (i.e., no review session was held,and then a review session was held) to trends in test scores across semesters (t−1, t) whereRi,t−1 = 0 and Rit = 0 (i.e., no review session was held in either consecutive semester).Using potential outcomes notation, state the estimand and formalize the two key assump-tions for it to identify a causal parameter (you do not need to prove identification).
(c)
Show that randomization of Rit satisfies both sets of identifying assumptions in (a) and(b).
(d)
How would you tell Stata (or any other language) to compute standard errors in eitherestimation strategy? How concerned would you be if you only randomized review sessionsacross T = 2 semesters?
(e)
Do the two approaches in (a) and (b) identify the same causal parameter or differentcausal parameters? Explain

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *