Consider the market for car rentals on the island of Oahu. One firm, BigCar, has long been the only rental car company on the island. Recently, however, more freight ferry routes have been established, allowing smaller firms to enter the rental car market and jeopardize BigCar’s established monopoly. However, these smaller firms incur higher costs in supplying rentals than BigCar does due to their added expense of transporting cars to the island.
Demand in this market is represented by the following equation:
Q = 100 − P
where Q is the quantity of car rentals per day, and P is the per-day rental rate in dollars per rental.
BigCar faces marginal cost curve:
MC
big
= Q
big
+ 10
where MC
big
is the marginal cost in dollars per day of supplying an additional car rental, and Q is the quantity of car rentals per day supplied by BigCar.
The small firms are collectively represented by the marginal cost curve below – which is also their inverse supply curve – where Q
small
is the quantity of car rentals per day supplied by small firms:
MC
small
= 20 + (1/3) Q
small
As the largest firm on the market, BigCar is the price-setting firm. The small firms operate as price-takers in a competitive market, making their production decisions based on whatever price BigCar sets.
Imagine, first, that there were no small firms in the market, and BigCar were the sole supplier of car rentals.
a. [5 marks] Calculate the equilibrium price and quantity in the market, as well as the Consumer Surplus, Producer Surplus for BigCar, and the Lerner Index.
b. [8 marks] Calculate and draw on a chart BigCar’s residual demand curve: at each level of price, the quantity that Big Car sells is equal to the difference between the quantity demanded and the quantity supplied by the small firms at this price. Also include the market demand curve and the small firms’ supply curve.
c. [5 marks] Calculate BigCar’s residual marginal revenue, corresponding to its residual demand curve. Calculate the equilibrium price and quantity in the market supplied by Big Car. (Hint: To maximize profit, Big Car will choose the level of production that sets its residual marginal revenue equal to marginal cost. It will then set the price according to its residual demand). Calculate the quantity of rentals supplied by small firms at the equilibrium price. Check that the quantity supplied should be equal to the quantity demanded at the equilibrium.
d. [5 marks] Calculate Consumer Surplus, Producer Surplus for BigCar, Producer Surplus for the small firms, and the Lerner Index for BigCar.
e. [2 marks] Who benefits from the introduction of small firms? Who does not? What is the change in total surplus?
Leave a Reply