State 3 objections to the theory of normative ethical relativism
Makes moral critique and progress impossible: If moral truth is entirely determined by a group or culture, then reformers within a culture (or critics of other cultures) can never be right—moral reform and claims of moral improvement become meaningless.
Self-refutation and inconsistency: The claim that “there are no objective moral truths” appears to be an objective, universal claim; if relativism asserts universal prescriptions (e.g., “tolerance is always right”), it undermines its own thesis.
Permits or fails to condemn obviously harmful practices: Relativism offers no principled way to condemn actions widely seen as morally abhorrent (e.g., genocide, slavery, systematic oppression), making it difficult to justify moral opposition or cross-cultural moral intervention.
Leave a Reply